Chris Raad · 20 November 2026

Does Afterpay increase conversion? The randomised evidence, what Afterpay, Zip and Shop Pay claims measure, the 2025 BNPL rules, fees and how to test it.

Buy now, pay later can lift conversion, and the best evidence says by a lot for the right store: a randomised test at a German online furniture retailer found that offering it raised conversions 13% and revenue per customer about 20% (Berg and others, NBER 2024). Most figures you will see from Afterpay, Zip and Shopify measure something else, such as how much BNPL users spend compared with similar shoppers. Whether BNPL pays for an Australian store comes down to who your customers are, how much the extra orders outweigh a fee several points above cards, and a test on your own checkout.

This post separates the independent evidence from the vendor claims, explains the 2025 Australian rules and the 2026 surcharging change, works through the fee arithmetic, and sets out how to test BNPL on your own store.

Does Afterpay increase conversion rate?

Offering a pay-later option increased conversion in the one randomised test we found, and the effect came mostly from shoppers who were less able to pay up front. No published randomised test measures Afterpay or Zip at an Australian store. Afterpay's own figures describe its users' spending, not what happens to a store's conversion rate when it switches Afterpay on.

The likely answer is yes for stores whose customers budget their spending and whose products are hard to buy elsewhere, the two conditions under which the German effect was strongest. The size of the lift is something you measure; the cost you can calculate in advance.

What does independent research show?

The strongest study is a randomised controlled trial, published by Tobias Berg, Valentin Burg, Jan Keil and Manju Puri as NBER working paper 33152 (November 2024) and in the Journal of Financial Economics (2025). A German online furniture retailer showed its pay-later option to some customers at checkout and hid it from others at random, over about two weeks in February and March 2022. "Conversion" in the study means a customer who reached the checkout page went on to buy; 71% did.

MeasureResult when BNPL was offered
Customers in each group74,128 shown BNPL; 948 not shown
ConversionUp 9 percentage points, or 13%
Spend by customers who would have bought anywayUp 4% to 8%
Revenue per customerUp €40.80 to €47.20, or 18% to 21%
Who responded mostCustomers with the lowest credit scores responded two to three times as strongly as those with the highest
Customers declined creditAbout 13%
Retailer's cost of running BNPL2.1% of sales (defaults 1.17%, cost of capital 0.89%), against 0.9% for its other payment options

Source: Berg, Burg, Keil and Puri, The Economics of Buy Now, Pay Later: A Merchant's Perspective. The authors conclude that "BNPL increases sales by 20%, driven by low-creditworthiness customers and products where market power is larger", and that the benefits outweighed the costs for this merchant.

Four differences matter before you apply it to an Australian store:

  • The retailer ran BNPL itself as a single bill due 14 days after delivery, and paid 2.1% of sales to do so. Afterpay and Zip split the price into instalments, and an Australian store pays the provider's fee instead. Australians pay mostly by card (RBA, 2022 survey).
  • BNPL was already this retailer's most used payment method, at 51% of payments, ahead of PayPal at 39% and cards at 6%, so the starting point differs from an Australian store's.
  • Furniture orders are large: converting customers who didn't get BNPL spent €314 on average. The effect on a AU$60 order may be smaller.
  • The control group was small (948 customers), so the ranges are wide even though the effect is statistically significant.

A second study, by Marco Di Maggio, Justin Katz and Emily Williams (NBER working paper 30508, 2022), used US transaction data and found that "BNPL access increases both total spending levels and the retail share in total spending". It supports the direction of the German result from the shopper's side, without a conversion figure for merchants.

What do Afterpay, Zip and Shop Pay claim?

Each provider publishes figures from its own research, and each measures something different from a store's conversion rate.

ProviderClaimMethod statedWhat it measures
AfterpayActive users "spent 54% more overall"; "average order value was 28% higher"Mastercard study, June 2022: Afterpay consumers against a lookalike control group over 12 monthsHow Afterpay users spend compared with similar non-users; people who choose Afterpay may differ in ways the lookalike doesn't capture
Afterpay48% of active users "would shop elsewhere if Afterpay wasn't available"Afterpay Brand Equity Tracking, Australia and New Zealand, November 2023What users say they would do, not what they did
Afterpay4.4 million active ANZ customersNot statedAudience size
ZipNo conversion figure on its Australian business page; "2 million Aussie customers", credit limits AU$1,000 to AU$50,000Not statedAudience size
Shop Pay"As much as 50% better conversion compared to guest checkout"; "at least 10%" better than other accelerated checkouts; "5% lift in lower funnel conversion" from its presence"An external study completed with a Big Three global management consulting firm in April 2023"; no sample or definitionShop Pay as a wallet across Shopify stores; not BNPL

Sources: Afterpay for retailers, Zip for business and Shop Pay, read 20 November 2026.

The Afterpay comparison is the one most often repeated as a conversion figure, and it isn't one. Shoppers who choose Afterpay are a self-selected group; comparing them with lookalikes tells you they spend more, not that your store would sell more by adding the button.

Shop Pay belongs in a different decision. It is an express wallet that fills in saved details, like Apple Pay and Google Pay. Our own evidence on wallets comes from Paperlake, a store we run on Stripe: moving payment onto the price screen with Apple Pay and Google Pay took checkout sessions that paid from 25% (23 March to 18 June 2026) to 50% (1 October to 17 November 2026), through a price rise. Shop Pay Installments, Shopify's own pay-later option, is in early access in Australia for orders of AU$50 to AU$30,000 and needs Shopify Payments and Shop Pay.

How many Australians use buy now, pay later?

BNPL was 2% of Australian retail payments in 2025, with transactions more than doubling over the past five years, according to the RBA's June 2026 issues paper. Use is concentrated among younger shoppers. In the RBA's 2022 Consumer Payments Survey, almost one-third of Australians had used BNPL in the past year, over 40% of 18 to 39 year olds and 10% of those aged 65 and over, while BNPL made up 0.7% of the number of payments. The 2025 survey no longer reports BNPL separately.

A small share of payments with a large share of younger users means BNPL matters most for stores selling to people under 40, and least for stores whose buyers are older or buying for work.

What changed in BNPL regulation in Australia?

Since 10 June 2025, anyone engaging in credit activities involving buy now, pay later contracts must hold an Australian credit licence, according to ASIC. The change followed the Treasury Laws Amendment (Responsible Buy Now Pay Later and Other Measures) Act 2024. ASIC's Regulatory Guide 281 says "most buy now pay later contracts are regulated as low cost credit contracts", with modified responsible lending checks that the provider carries out.

For a store, three things follow:

  1. Providers now check whether the product suits the customer, so some shoppers who were approved before may be declined. In the German study, about 13% of applicants were declined.
  2. Describe the product in the provider's words. Afterpay's Australian merchant agreement says you "must not make any warranty, representation or statement to any Customer relating to Afterpay" beyond its own materials.
  3. You can't pass the fee on. The same agreement says you "must not impose a surcharge on the Customer", and counts "any charge or increase in the sale price, shipping costs" as a surcharge.

Card surcharges ended at the same time. The RBA decided on 31 March 2026 to remove surcharging on debit, prepaid and credit cards on the eftpos, Mastercard and Visa networks, with most changes taking effect on 1 October 2026, and its Payments System Board reported on 19 November 2026 that "merchants have broadly stopped surcharging transactions over these card networks". BNPL wasn't part of that decision. The RBA's June 2026 issues paper notes the cost of accepting BNPL "remains materially higher on average than for card payments" and raises "no-surcharge rules imposed by some BNPL providers" as a concern it is consulting on.

What does BNPL cost an Australian merchant?

BNPL costs several percentage points more than a card payment. Afterpay doesn't publish its direct rate; its fee page says the fee is a fixed amount plus a percentage set in your merchant agreement. Through Square, Afterpay is 6% plus 30 cents a transaction, excluding GST. Zip says its fees are "tailored to your business". Shopify Payments card rates start at 1.7% plus 30 cents on the Basic plan (Shopify AU pricing).

Here is the arithmetic for a store deciding whether BNPL pays. The inputs are assumptions; use your own fee and margin:

LineFigure
Online revenueAU$3M a year
Share of revenue that moves to BNPL from cards20%, or AU$600,000
Fee difference6% − 1.7% = 4.3 percentage points (fixed fees equal)
Extra fees on revenue you would have had anywayAU$600,000 × 4.3% = AU$25,800 a year
Margin kept on each new BNPL dollar at 40% gross margin, less the 6% fee34%
New revenue needed to break evenAU$25,800 ÷ 0.34 = AU$75,882, or 2.5% of revenue

A 2.5% lift is well under the 13% conversion increase in the German study, which is why many stores keep BNPL even at these fees. The arithmetic turns against BNPL when margins are thin, when most BNPL users would have bought with a card anyway, or when your customers rarely use it.

Where should BNPL messaging go on a product page?

Show the payment options where the shopper decides to buy: beside the price on the product page, again in the cart, and as a payment method at checkout. Shoppers who leave because they can't see how they can pay are counted in Baymard's survey: 9% of US abandoners left because there weren't enough payment methods, and 12% because they couldn't see or calculate the total up front (Baymard). We found no independent test of where instalment messaging works best, so the placement rule follows the decision: put the information where the shopper is weighing the price.

Most Australian stores already show it there, but not all of them show the amount. In our census of 717 of the most visible Australian Shopify stores (20 November 2026), 45.7% showed an instalment message on the product page: Afterpay on 36.1%, Zip on 11.0% and Klarna on 1.8%. Another 14.1% showed only a provider's logo, icon or banner with no instalment amount, which tells the shopper BNPL exists without telling them what each payment would be.

Use the provider's own widgets and wording; Afterpay's terms bar statements about Afterpay beyond its own materials. If your average order is under the provider's minimum or over its limit for a new customer, the message misleads more than it helps; check the amounts in your merchant agreement.

On Shopify, Afterpay and Zip connect as payment methods. Their on-site messaging sits in your theme, so it works on every plan. Our post on what you can change in Shopify checkout covers what each plan allows inside checkout itself.

How do you test whether BNPL lifts your conversion?

Measure checkout completion, average order and the share of orders paid with BNPL for at least eight weeks before you add it, then the same weeks after it and the same weeks a year earlier. Shopify can't randomise payment methods for you, so a before-and-after comparison is the realistic test for most stores.

  1. Record the baseline: sessions that completed checkout divided by sessions that reached checkout in Shopify's conversion rate breakdown report, average order value, and revenue per visitor.
  2. Turn BNPL on and add its product page messaging at the same time, so one change explains the result.
  3. Export orders and group them by the Payment Method column to see the BNPL share and its average order.
  4. Compare checkout completion and revenue per visitor after the change with the baseline and with the same weeks a year earlier, to separate the change from the season.
  5. Subtract the extra fees from the extra margin using the table above.

A randomised test is possible on Shopify Plus, where a developer can build a custom payment customisation function that hides the BNPL method for a random half of carts. Detecting a 13% lift in checkout completion from a 50% baseline needs about 920 checkouts in each group at 95% confidence and 80% power, about 1,850 in total; a store reaching 1,000 checkouts a month needs about two months. Check your provider's merchant terms before you hide its option from anyone.

Measure the whole store, not only the BNPL orders. A shopper who switches from card to Afterpay adds fees without adding a sale, so a rising BNPL share proves nothing by itself. The test is whether checkout completion and revenue per visitor rise by more than the fees cost. For the full diagnosis of where your checkout loses shoppers, start with why people add to cart but don't check out.

Sources

Questions

Does Afterpay increase conversion rate?

It can. The strongest independent evidence is a randomised test at a German online furniture retailer in early 2022: offering buy now, pay later raised conversions by 9 percentage points (13%) and revenue per customer by 18% to 21%, mostly from customers with lower credit scores (Berg, Burg, Keil and Puri, NBER 2024). Afterpay's own figures compare its users with similar shoppers and do not measure conversion.

How much does Afterpay cost merchants in Australia?

Afterpay doesn't publish its direct merchant rate; its fee page says it is a fixed fee plus a percentage set in your merchant agreement. Through Square, Afterpay costs 6% plus 30 cents a transaction excluding GST. The RBA says BNPL costs merchants materially more on average than card payments, and Afterpay's terms don't allow you to surcharge it.

Do I need a credit licence to offer Afterpay or Zip?

ASIC requires anyone engaging in credit activities involving buy now, pay later contracts to hold an Australian credit licence from 10 June 2025. That obligation and the suitability checks sit with the provider. Merchants should follow the provider's merchant terms on how they describe the product; Afterpay's bar statements about Afterpay beyond its own materials.

Does Shop Pay increase conversion?

Shopify says Shop Pay converts as much as 50% better than guest checkout and at least 10% better than other accelerated checkouts, based on an external study by a Big Three consulting firm in April 2023. Shopify publishes no sample or method for that study, so treat it as a vendor claim. Shop Pay is a wallet; Shop Pay Installments, its pay-later option, is in early access in Australia.

Can I surcharge customers for paying with Afterpay?

No. Afterpay's Australian merchant agreement says you must not impose a surcharge on a customer for using Afterpay, and defines a surcharge to include any increase in the sale price or shipping costs. Card surcharges on eftpos, Mastercard and Visa also ended from 1 October 2026 under the RBA's reforms.

We'll show you what your customers do on it.

Apply for a free teardown